I was curious to know why you are having this problem, thinking that maybe my pedal was faulty, so I checked with ohm meter and found that only 150-300 ohms when driving. I opened it and saw that the switch uses an elastomer, and this high "on" resistance is a characteristic of these switches. It seems that Yamaha will be reduced "on" switch blade switch resistance to SP-2 is not enough to see Yamaha switches are closed, how to "do".
Mine seems to be reliable (so far), and may not be enough differences between individuals, that this problem can not occur with all users of Yamaha. I would buy another SP-2, but I want to make sure I knew the store refund if you want to use the Yamaha keyboard. Moreover, even if everyone is talking about a "support" does not allow the pedal support "partial" true Yamaha FC-3 supports some Yamaha digital piano, the pedal must be used for "soft", "sustained" or "aux" functions of the CP300.
Read more reviews M-Audio SP-2 US65010 Sustain Pedal Piano Style Sustain Pedal for Keyboards